| Platinum | Porky's Pizza |
| Gold | Big Guy's Pizza, Pasta and Sports Bar |
| Silver | Shakey's Pizza Parlor |
| Bronze | Mountain Mike's Pizza |
| Top Pick | All Star Pizza |
| Top Pick | BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse |
| Top Pick | Joe's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Round Table Pizza |